Comparisons

Lexis+ AI vs Spellbook: Which Should I Choose?

Choose Lexis+ AI (now Lexis+ with Protégé) if your firm needs AI research grounded in LexisNexis case law and Shepard's. Choose Spellbook if your lawyers mostly draft and review contracts in Microsoft Word. Neither publishes prices as of November 2026, so get written quotes.

A law office desk with a laptop showing a marked-up contract on one side and a stack of case law books and a legal pad on the other.

Quick answer

Choose Lexis+ AI (now sold as Lexis+ with Protégé) if your firm's main need is legal research and litigation drafting backed by LexisNexis content and Shepard's citation checks. Choose Spellbook if your lawyers spend most of their day drafting and redlining contracts in Microsoft Word.

Lexis+ AI or Spellbook: which one should my firm choose?

Pick Lexis+ AI if your firm's AI work starts with research. Pick Spellbook if it starts with contracts. LexisNexis now sells Lexis+ AI as Lexis+ with Protégé, and it fits litigators and research-heavy firms that want answers grounded in LexisNexis primary law and checked with Shepard's. Spellbook fits transactional lawyers who draft, review and redline contracts inside Microsoft Word. OpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi) fits firms whose real bottleneck is back-office work like intake, client follow-ups and document collection, not research or redlining.

One disclosure: we build one of these tools. Lexi, the AI paralegal in OpenLaw for Attorneys, gets one entry and one honest take, same as the rest. It's on this page because people comparing these tools also ask what Lexi replaces. It is not a research database and not a contract redliner. Lexi is made by OpenLaw. It has nothing to do with getlexi.io, a different company that is also named Lexi.

This page is for law firm owners, partners and administrators choosing where to spend their AI budget. We checked prices, security pages and product pages in November 2026.

Lexis+ AI vs Spellbook vs OpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi), side by side, as of November 2026
QuestionLexis+ with Protégé (formerly Lexis+ AI)SpellbookOpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi)
Who makes itLexisNexisSpellbookOpenLaw (not getlexi.io)
Primary jobLegal research, document analysis and drafting grounded in LexisNexis contentContract drafting, review and redlining in Microsoft WordBack-office firm work: intake recalls, client calls, follow-up emails, document collection, filings prep
Best forLitigators and research-heavy practices, especially firms already on LexisTransactional lawyers and in-house teamsFirms that want staff time back on routine operations
Where you use itWeb, mobile apps and Microsoft Word add-inMicrosoft Word add-in plus the Associate agentConnected to firm tools such as Clio Manage and Google Calendar
Case law researchYes, with Shepard's citation checksNo case law database is listed on its pricing pageNo
Pricing modelQuote onlyQuote only, by number of team members on the licenseNot published; demo first
Free trialNot published on the pages we checked7 daysNot published

What does each tool actually do?

Lexis+ with Protégé is a research platform with AI on top. Spellbook is a contract tool that lives in Word. Lexi handles a firm's operations work. They overlap less than the "vs" in the search suggests.

Lexis+ with Protégé (formerly Lexis+ AI)

LexisNexis built Protégé on its own content library: primary law, secondary sources, Practical Guidance and Shepard's. According to Lawyerist's review, it handles conversational research with linked citations, drafts transactional documents, motions, briefs and complaints, and summarizes uploaded files. It runs in a browser, on mobile apps and as a Word add-in.

On May 7, 2026, LexisNexis added several features, as LawSites reported:

  • Protégé Work: turns a plain-English request into a plan and then into work product.
  • Agentic Drafting: drafting agents for contracts, motions, briefs and deal documents.
  • Vault: holds up to 100,000 documents per vault, including audio, video and images.
  • Shepard's Verify: flags citations it cannot verify. It confirms that an authority exists, not that the authority supports the point it's cited for.
  • BYOK: lets the firm hold its own encryption keys.

Spellbook

Spellbook is an AI add-in for Microsoft Word, built for contracts. Its pricing page lists the Spellbook Suite (Review, Draft, Ask, Benchmarks and Playbooks), Associate (a multi-document agent), Compare (which checks contracts against industry standards) and an early-access contract management product. The page lists no case law research. If your team works on litigation, read whether Spellbook can be used for litigation before you buy.

OpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi)

Lexi takes on firm operations instead of research or redlining. The OpenLaw for Attorneys page lists booking intake recalls, returning client calls, sending follow-up emails, drafting engagement letters and client updates, collecting documents, preparing filings and posting payments. Lexi drafts client emails for an attorney to approve before anything goes out. For the full list, see what Lexi does for a law firm.

Published pricing for Lexis+ AI, Spellbook and Lexi, checked November 2026. Treat any number as a starting point for negotiation.
PlanPrice per seat, per monthCheckedSource
Lexis+ with ProtégéNot published; quote based on firm size, features and contentNovember 2026LexisNexis store and Lawyerist review
Spellbook (law firms or in-house)Not published; quote based on number of team members; 7-day free trialNovember 2026spellbook.com/pricing
OpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi)Not published; book a demoNovember 2026openlaw.com/attorneys

How much do Lexis+ AI and Spellbook cost?

Neither company publishes a price as of November 2026. You'll need a sales quote for either one. Spellbook bases its quote on how many team members are on the license. LexisNexis prices by firm size, the features you choose and how much content you need.

Third-party blogs post per-seat estimates for both tools, but the numbers disagree with each other and none comes from the vendor, so we left them out. When you ask for quotes, pin down these points in writing:

  • Seat minimums and term length: a low per-seat price can come with an annual commitment or a minimum number of seats.
  • What the AI seat includes: with Lexis, check whether Protégé comes bundled with your Lexis+ research plan or costs extra, and which content packages your quote covers.
  • Trial terms: Spellbook's pricing page offers a 7-day free trial and longer trials for bigger teams. Ask Lexis what trial it will give you.
  • Billing clients: ABA Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers can't bill clients for time spent learning a tool they'll use regularly.

To see how Spellbook compares with a lower-cost rival, read which is cheaper, NexLaw or Spellbook.

Security and privilege: what each vendor publishes, checked November 2026
QuestionLexis+ with ProtégéSpellbookOpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi)
SOC 2SOC 2 Type 2 and Type 1 reports in the LexisNexis Trust CenterSOC 2 Type II compliant, per its security pageRuns on infrastructure covered by an issued SOC 2 Type II report
Training on your uploadsTrust Center: "We do not train or fine-tune our AI models using Customer Data"Not stated on its security page; zero data retention agreements with OpenAI and AnthropicFirm skills and workflows are not shared with AI labs, per its product page
Other certificationsISO/IEC 27001GDPR, CCPA, PIPEDA; will sign a HIPAA BAAEncryption in transit and at rest
Customer-held keysYes, Protégé BYOK (May 2026)Not statedNot stated

Are Lexis+ AI and Spellbook safe for privileged client data?

Both vendors publish enterprise-grade security commitments, and that matters more since February 2026. Still, no vendor's terms guarantee privilege. Your firm's policies and contract terms carry as much weight as the vendor's.

In United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., No. 1:25-cr-00503), Judge Jed Rakoff ruled from the bench on February 10, 2026 and issued a written opinion on February 17, 2026. He held that a defendant's chats with a consumer AI tool were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor work product. The tool's terms allowed the provider to use prompts for training and to disclose data, so the chats weren't confidential, and the defendant hadn't used the tool at counsel's direction. As Proskauer's alert notes, the court did not decide how enterprise tools with no-training and confidentiality terms would fare.

Here is what each vendor puts in writing:

  • LexisNexis: the LexisNexis Trust Center says it does not train or fine-tune its AI models on customer data, and it offers SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO/IEC 27001 documents.
  • Spellbook: its security page shows SOC 2 Type II, says it has zero data retention agreements with OpenAI and Anthropic, and says it will sign a HIPAA business associate agreement. The page doesn't say directly whether Spellbook itself trains on uploads, so get that in your contract.

ABA Formal Opinion 512, issued July 29, 2024, requires lawyers to weigh disclosure risk before entering client information into a generative AI tool. It says boilerplate consent in an engagement letter isn't enough when a tool learns from client data. It also requires managing lawyers to set firm-wide AI policies.

Tip: Whichever tool you choose, ask for the SOC 2 report itself and the data processing terms, and keep both with your firm's AI policy.

Where does Lexis+ AI still win, and where does Spellbook still win?

Each tool clearly wins in its own lane. Trouble starts when a firm buys one to do the other's job.

Where Lexis+ AI still wins

  • Authority-backed research: answers come from LexisNexis content, with Shepard's checking the citations.
  • Litigation drafting: motions, briefs and complaints, plus agentic drafting since May 2026.
  • Large document sets: Vault holds up to 100,000 documents, and outputs link back to the source passages.
  • Firms already on Lexis: you add AI to a research subscription you already pay for and train on.
  • Key control: BYOK lets the firm revoke access to its encrypted data.

Where Spellbook still wins

  • Staying in Word: contract lawyers draft and redline without leaving the document.
  • Contract-specific features: Playbooks, Benchmarks and Compare are built around contract terms and market standards.
  • Easy to try: a 7-day free trial on its pricing page.
  • In-house fit: the in-house plan includes a service that builds your playbook for you.

Where Lexi fits instead

Neither tool returns client calls, books intake recalls or collects documents. If those tasks are filling your staff's day, compare Lexi against your operations workload, not against a research database.

Can firms use both Lexis+ AI and Spellbook?

Yes, and plenty of full-service firms should. The tools barely overlap. Litigators use Lexis+ with Protégé for research and briefs, and the transactional group uses Spellbook for contract review in Word.

The cost of doing both is duplicated seats and two vendor security reviews. Buy seats by practice group instead of licensing everyone for both tools. Check whether the Lexis drafting features, including the Word add-in and the May 2026 agentic drafting for contracts, already cover enough contract work that your transactional team doesn't need Spellbook. If you're weighing other contract tools, see the best Spellbook alternatives in 2026.

Should I choose Lexis+ AI or Spellbook?

Base the choice on the work that fills your lawyers' hours, not on brand names.

Choose Lexis+ with Protégé if:

  • Most of your billable work is litigation, research memos or briefs.
  • You need citations checked against an authoritative database.
  • You already subscribe to Lexis+ and want AI on the content you know.
  • Your clients' security questionnaires ask about customer-held encryption keys.

Choose Spellbook if:

  • Most of your work is drafting, reviewing and negotiating contracts.
  • Your lawyers live in Microsoft Word and won't switch to a separate app.
  • You want contract playbooks and market benchmarks.
  • You'd like to try it for a week before talking price.

Choose OpenLaw for Attorneys (Lexi) if:

  • Intake, client follow-ups, document collection and payment posting take up more staff time than research or redlining.

The verdict: Lexis+ AI is the research and litigation pick, and Spellbook is the contract pick. A firm that does both kinds of work can reasonably buy both, by practice group.

Frequently asked questions

What is Spellbook used for?

Spellbook is used for drafting, reviewing and redlining contracts inside Microsoft Word. Its suite includes Review, Draft, Ask, Benchmarks and Playbooks, plus Associate, a multi-document agent, and Compare, which checks contracts against industry standards. Law firm transactional groups and in-house legal teams are its main users.

Does Spellbook Offer Legal Research?

No, not case law research. Spellbook's pricing page lists contract features such as Review, Draft, Ask, Benchmarks and Playbooks, but no case law database or citation checker. Firms that need research grounded in primary law usually pair Spellbook with a research platform such as Lexis+ with Protégé.

How Much Does Spellbook Cost?

Spellbook doesn't publish a price as of November 2026. Its pricing page says the price depends on the number of team members on the license, offers a 7-day free trial and asks you to book a demo for a quote. Third-party estimates vary widely, so get a written quote for your seat count and term.

Is Spellbook Built for Law Firms or In-House Counsel?

Both. Spellbook's pricing page has separate plans for law firms and in-house teams. Both include the Word add-in and Associate. The law firm plan adds group training, and the in-house plan adds team training and a playbook build service. Teams over 10 get dedicated support on either plan.

Which Spellbook alternatives work inside Microsoft Word?

Lexis+ with Protégé is one. Lawyerist reports it offers features as a Microsoft Word add-in, and LexisNexis's Lexis Create+ drafting tool opens from the Word ribbon. LexisNexis also said in May 2026 that its agentic drafting outputs can be delivered as Word drafts. Confirm which Word features your subscription includes.

Is it easy to switch from Spellbook to an alternative?

Usually, yes. Spellbook works on Word documents your firm already stores, so your contracts stay with you. The real work is rebuilding custom playbooks and retraining lawyers. Check your notice period and commitment term before you switch, and run a trial of the new tool first.

Are AI contract drafting tools reliable for legal teams?

Sometimes. They speed up first drafts and issue spotting, but a lawyer still has to verify every output. ABA Formal Opinion 512 requires lawyers to understand a tool's limits and review its work. Even LexisNexis's Shepard's Verify confirms only that a cited authority exists, not that it supports the point.

What does Lexi replace in a law firm?

Lexi takes over routine back-office tasks, not tools like Lexis or Spellbook. According to OpenLaw for Attorneys, it books intake recalls, returns client calls, sends follow-up emails, drafts engagement letters and client updates, collects documents, prepares filings and posts payments. Attorneys approve client emails before they go out.

Does Lexi replace lawyers or paralegals?

No. OpenLaw for Attorneys says attorneys stay in control of review, strategy and judgment, and that AI can make mistakes. Lexi handles repetitive tasks and asks for input when it needs it, which frees paralegals and staff for work that takes judgment rather than replacing them.

Does Lexi replace practice management software?

No. Lexi works alongside practice management software. The OpenLaw for Attorneys page shows it connecting to Clio Manage, Thomson Reuters and Google Calendar. Your firm keeps its system of record, and Lexi does the tasks around it.

Sources

  1. Spellbook Pricing, Spellbook
  2. Spellbook Security, Spellbook
  3. LexisNexis Trust Center, LexisNexis
  4. Lexis+ with Protégé, LexisNexis
  5. Lexis Create+ Legal Document Drafting Solution, LexisNexis UK
  6. Lexis+ with Protégé Review: Features, Cost, Pros & Cons (2026), Lawyerist
  7. LexisNexis Expands Lexis+ with Protégé, Adding Agentic Skills, Collaboration Workrooms, and Customer-Held Encryption Keys, LawSites (LawNext)
  8. SDNY Addresses Privilege and Work Product Implications of Using Unsecured Public AI Tools, Proskauer Rose LLP
  9. United States v. Heppner, Harvard Law Review
  10. ABA issues first ethics guidance on a lawyer's use of AI tools, American Bar Association
  11. OpenLaw for Attorneys, OpenLaw